OKLAHOMA CITY — When a back-to-back MVP candidate starts a season sitting at 45 percent from the field, the talking heads and fans on social media love to sound the alarm. Fans see the raw shooting numbers dip and assume something is broken in his bag. But a deep-dive into Shai Gilgeous-Alexander shooting “struggles” reveals a perfect storm—a mixture of early-season variance, stricter officiating rules, and the heavy burden of carrying a depleted roster through an injury crisis.
“Every experience is different, teaches you a new thing—good or bad—and you just take it, learn from it, and move on,” Shai noted when asked about adapting to more physical defensive coverages. Keeping that perspective in mind helps separate the panic from what the actual film shows.
Opponents Double Up As Injury Wave Shrinks The Floor
Losing key creators like Jalen Williams has stripped away a lot of playmaking around SGA, allowing opposing defenses to build wall-to-wall traps against the reigning MVP’s drives.
When you don’t have offensive hubs on the floor, defenses stop respecting the weak side and tilt multiple bodies toward SGA. Over this recent stretch without Williams, teams have been blitzing the pick-and-roll and daring role players to beat them instead. Without that safety of his running mates and despite the best efforts of Ajay Mitchell, Shai is forced to fight through multiple bodies sometimes just to get a clean look inside the arc.
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander Shooting Efficiency Breakdown: The Off-Arm Crackdown
Referees policing the off arm push off rule much tighter this year strips away Shai’s subtle off-arm nudge, forcing him into tougher contests on his mid-range pull-ups.
Instead of getting to his spot and creating a full yard of separation with his trademark deceleration step, defenders are allowed to ride his hip without getting whistled for a foul. That tiny adjustment partly explains why his two-point conversion rate dropped from a center-like 60 percent down to 50 percent. He is still getting to his spots, but without that extra inch of space, he’s firing over outstretched hands rather than clean air. The NBA is a league that plays on razor thin margins.
Last season, Shai shot 58.7 percent on 2-pointers under tight coverage (2–4 feet). This year, nearly half of his 2-point attempts (43.5 percent frequency) are coming under tight 2–4 foot contests, causing his efficiency on those looks to plummet to 48.3 percent.
That sticky defense shows up clearly in his mid-range diet. After hitting an electric 54.9 percent on mid-range jumpers last season (and 57.3 percent from 8–16 feet), Shai has slid to 46.7 percent from mid-range through the opening stretch.
You can see this exact resistance manifest in high-volume nights—such as his 43-point outing against Cleveland where he went 14-of-35 from the field. Breaking down that specific shot chart reveals he made only 5 shots directly at the rim, grinding out his other buckets through contested pull-ups and 4 triples. When defenders are permitted to stay attached to his hip without yielding space, his shooting takes a hit like we saw last night when he made just five of his 20 shots from the midrange area.
Where Did The Whistle Go?
Whistles drying up across the league has caused a sharp drop in SGA free throw attempts, robbing him of those easy, momentum-building points at the charity stripe.
Over the last two seasons, Shai generated nearly eight free points a night by attacking the rack and forcing contact on jumpers. Currently averaging exactly five free throw attempts per game, he isn’t getting those soft bailouts when possessions stall out.
- 2024–25 Season: 7.9 free throws made per game on 90% shooting.
- 2025–26 Season: 7.9 free throws made per game on 88% shooting.
- 2026–27 Season (Current Split): 5.0 free throws made per game on 88% shooting.
When you aren’t getting those routine trips to the line, you have to “settle” for jumpers. SGA is taking the most mi
Spacing Needs Room To Breathe
Expanding the rotation with fringe players while missing key personnel alters Thunder’s spacing, turning driving lanes into heavily congested traffic jams.
Opponents are packing the paint and daring young role players to beat them from deep. Even with extra bodies collapsing on his drives, Shai’s ability to grind out 43 points against the Cavaliers proves he can still get to his spots whenever he flips the switch.
Running a proper Shai Gilgeous-Alexander shooting efficiency breakdown shows he is simply adjusting to how the league is officiated while carrying a massive offensive load. The enforcement of the off arm push off rule and defensive traps created a temporary speed bump, but SGA remains too lethal of a scorer to stay grounded for long.
Find me on X: @f_rederic_k
